The NHL All Star-Game is coming up in a bit, and there have been some interesting twists and turns along the way. Ovechkin falling in the standings amid his sudden goal scoring drought, Kris Letang becoming the #1 voted for defenseman despite being a write in candidate, Sean Avery actually getting votes, etc. But one thing stands out here: this is a popularity contest, plain and simple. In general the good players get a lot of votes, but sometimes players who are truly elite but just aren’t flashy or as promoted league-wide as other ones and don’t receive as many ballots. If you voted for Marc-Andre Fleury or for that matter Sergei Bobrovsky because you believe that they’re really the best goalie in the league, well then you’re full of shit. If you voted for them because they are your teams’ goalie and you want to see them play in the All-Star Game, fine. I honestly have no problem with people voting for their team’s players because they have team loyalty. Like I said, it’s a popularity contest. People vote for who they want to see. However, I think a lot of people would like to see who’d be going to the All-Star Game if everyone voted based on skill. It would be interesting wouldn’t it? So I’m asking you, who would you put out there? Three forwards, two defensemen, and one goalie. Don’t completely disregard position, but feel free to put three centers out there if you feel like two of them could play left & right wing effectively. Assume all the players injured or sick right now are healthy. Give it a thought and write it out, and defend your choices. Leave your answer in the comments section below, I don’t wanna see this crap on facebook or whatever, I promise I only sell the email addresses to spam-bots when I’m strapped for cash.
Go.

I’m a Pittsburgh boy, and it’s pretty hard to argue with a guy who’s 10 points ahead of everyone else in the points race, and even so, Stamkos scores too high a percentage of his points on the Powerplay (it’s 47%) for me to really feel like he’s the Center I want skating 5 on 5, and no one else has more than 40 points thus far. Big surprise, my center is Sidney Crosby.
I’m handing out my Right Wing to a guy who’s also a Center, but I believe that he can absolutely handle the position change. The guy who redefined the move known as the deke: Pavel Datsyuk. For my defense of this choice, please just watch this:
The last forward up here, taking the position of Left Wing (I’m sure his twin brother will be sad to have been left out) is one Daniel Sedin. This guy was on pace to seriously challenge his twin for the Art Ross Trophy last year, and if it wasn’t for missing 19 games he’d have done it. 85 Points in 63 Games last year and on about the same pace this year. Enough said.
I strongly believe that you need a defenseman who can shoot and score from the blue line, and another who’s a big hitter who is solid defensively back in your own zone. My first choice for defenseman, and my offensive gun from the blue line: Dustin Byfuglien. Leading the defensemen scoring race commandingly, with 7 more points and 7 more goals than second place Kris Letang. Don’t take blocking his slapshot lightly, ask Max Talbot if it hurts (hint: it does). My defensive defenseman and bone snapping hitter is the tallest player in the NHL, Zdeno Chara. The Captain of the Bruins, Chara is 10th in the leagues +/- race despite playing for the team with the 12th most goals per game. Don’t mess with Chara, because your fists can’t even reach his face.
My goalie is another unsurprising choice, and the first choice to make two players from the same team. Tim Thomas.
Rationale: who’s face do you see here
-http://www.nhl.com/ice/statshome.htm#?navid=nav-sts-main-
the most?
Yeah, Thomas’s. He’s got a .951 SV%, 1.63 GAA, and 5 shutouts. Story over.
Those are my calls:
D. Sedin – Crosby – Datsyuk
Byfuglien – Chara
Thomas
Find better players, I dare you.
I honestly can’t disagree with any of your choices, though I’d rather have Jimmy Craig as my goalie, Mike Eruzione as my right wing, and Chris Chelios over Byfuglien =P
Haven’t seen a post in a while. I’m interested in your thoughts as the Pens struggle through a lot of injuries.